The Herald

The corrupt are punch-drunk but a small town punched back

As one disastrously run municipality has proved, it is possible to unite and boot out a useless ANC council

Maluti-a-Phofung municipality should be cited countrywide as an example of what happens when communities take political power back.
Maluti-a-Phofung municipality should be cited countrywide as an example of what happens when communities take political power back. Maluti-a-Phofung municipality should be cited countrywide as an example of what happens when communities take political power back. Picture: Supplied

Two stories stood out for me when reading this past weekend’s papers.

My colleague, investigative journalist Sabelo Skiti, blew the lid on a tender scam involving former senior managers in the office of the chief justice.

The three — former CFO Casper Coetzer, former case management director Yvonne van Niekerk, ex-spokesperson and former chief director of court administration Nathi Mncube — engaged in some questionable financial and ethical Olympics, what they call “javelin throwing” in political lexicon.

A day after they resigned from the office of the chief justice, they began work as directors of ZA Square Consulting, an entity subcontracted as local partners to multinational media and tech giant Thomson Reuters, which scored a R225m six-year contract for the rollout of a digital case management and litigation system that files court documents digitally.

Problem is they had been involved in the preparation of this system and the procurement process. The OCJ confirmed this fact when contacted by the Sunday Times for comment. 

“The OCJ can confirm that it was made aware of a subcontract between Thomson Reuters and the SA company in question (ZA Square Consulting). In addition, the OCJ can confirm that all the directors of the local company (Coetzer, Mncube and Van Niekerk) played a role in the process which led to the granting of an award by the OCJ to Thomson Reuters.”

Note that their 30% stake in the case management contract is worth a cool R67.5m.

There has been huge reaction to this story. Everyone agrees the tender stinks and should be reviewed as a matter of urgency.

In fact on Saturday evening when the paper was being put to bed I remarked to colleagues how naive these three were. I said pros at corruption would have covered their tracks much better.

In a twisted way I found myself pitying them, thinking how their naivety might have cost them from benefiting longer from their well-thought-out but poorly executed corrupt scheme.

I’ve had a chance to ponder this statement over the weekend and it shocks me just how problematic my remarks were. Are we so desensitised to corruption that we find ourselves debating the shortcomings of the latest corrupt party and better ways for perpetrators to cover their tracks?

In a twisted way I found myself pitying them, thinking how their naiveté might have cost them from benefiting longer from their well-thought-out but poorly executed corrupt scheme.

It scares me to think of how hardened we have become at news of embezzlement and theft of public funds; it no longer shocks or surprises us.

But why would we be shocked when on a daily basis we are served the latest episode of corrupt shenanigans by state officials or crooked deployed cadres? What has the ANC done to us?

I’m not suggesting the governing party sent Coetzer, Mncube and Van Niekerk to cook a tender; but would they have been so emboldened if there was no precedence, if corruption was not so entrenched in the government they served?

My second favourite read I found in City Press newspaper, syndicated from its sister paper, Rapport.

Residents of Phuthaditjhaba in the eastern Free State have water flowing from their taps for the first time in 13 years after kicking out the ANC administration in the troubled Maluti-a-Phofung municipality. Having given up on the hopeless ANC administration, residents formed the MAP-16 community organisation and put up candidates for the municipal elections. MAP-16 won 20 seats in council. Together with the EFF’s seven seats, three from Dikwankwetla party and one from the African Transformation Party (with informal support from the DA and the Freedom Front Plus) they were able to put together a coalition to run Maluti-a-Phofung themselves.

Upon assuming power, the coalition prioritised water and is now successfully restoring it. People who were forced to wake up at 3am every morning to queue for their daily 25-litre ration of water now no longer thirst for this basic commodity running out of their taps at home.

After decades of ANC mismanagement and corruption, there’s still a long way to go in fixing this broken town. It still owes Eskom a staggering R6.7bn, but it has entered into an agreement by which the utility has agreed to halt power cuts if the town keeps up with monthly payments. Plans are also being made to bring sewerage plants back into operation. 

Maluti-a-Phofung should be cited countrywide as an example of what happens when communities take political power back from corrupt ANC cadres and their incompetent administrations.

The ANC is its own worst enemy. Its leaders are incorrigible.

Look at President Cyril Ramaphosa fighting to stay in office because he was dishonest about a robbery at his private farm and still refuses to come clean. The least we can do is free him and his comrades of the responsibility of running this great country before they drag it completely down the abyss.