All high courts in SA are inherently Equality Courts, but when the Human Rights Commission approached the high court in Gqeberha recently, they were given the runaround and told there was no presiding officer equipped to hear such matters.
Justice delayed is justice denied and while Equality Courts have specifically been established to deal with issues of discrimination and hate speech, many complainants are being turned away because some courts do not cater for them.
On June 2, the SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) and a lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, queer and intersex (LGBTQI+) support group, OUT LGBT Well-Being, approached the city’s high court to institute legal action against SA singer Steve Hofmeyr for his alleged derogatory comments about the use of the plus (+) at the end of the acronym and newly launched streaming service Disney+.
Provincial human rights coordinator for OUT, Sibonelo Ncanana, who was at the court and had been sent, along with the SAHRC, from pillar to post while trying to file the complaint, said it was a frustration his community regularly experienced.
“I feel extremely frustrated, nothing gets done and we are sent from door-to-door,” he said.
“What about justice for our communities; a lot of people decide not to go through with laying complaints because they do not receive the assistance they deserve.”
SAHRC provincial manger Dr Eileen Carter said while the matter was eventually taken to a clerk of the court who had some training in Equality Court matters, it was a stumbling block that happened far too often.
“It is the first step; now we must wait and see how the court responds,” Carter said.
According to Carter, the Equality Act provides for the establishment of Equality Courts to implement the act, and it would fall to a judge to assist in the development of the law.
Carter said according to the guiding principles of the Equality Act, the development of special skills and capacity on creating and implementing a guide for the specific branch of the law at a high court was of high importance.
The provincial commissioner of the SAHRC, advocate Andre Gaum, said all high courts were inherently Equality Courts which should have a presiding officer, trained in equality matters, to help streamline the process.
“This is a prime example of why access to justice is so important. If we struggle to get the court to accept our papers, what about the lay person?”
Ncanana added that his recent experience at the high court proved that justice was inaccessible to most.
Access to Equality Courts should be for any person acting in their own interests, that of another, a group, organisation or association, including the SAHRC, Carter said.
“One of the guiding principles of the Equality Act is to allow access to justice in any jurisdiction with the role of the Equality Act to promote redress for victims of hate speech and unfair discrimination,” she said.
Approached for comment, the Office of the Chief Justice (OCJ) sent a statement which did not address specific issues and concerns raised by the SAHRC, who were told that there was no-one to deal with equality matters at the time.
They were eventually assisted by a magistrate’s court clerk who had some training in equality matters.
In the statement attributed to the OJC, it was confirmed that “at least one or more officials should be designated as clerks of the Equality Court at each court”.
According to the statement, there are three officials at the Gqeberha high court who are trained as clerks of the Equality Court.
The OJC confirmed an Equality Court case had been issued out of the court but “the institution of matters is not within the control of the court as a party is entitled to determine whether to bring the matter in the high court or the lower court”.
“There are presiding officers designated as presiding officers of the Equality Court on the judicial establishment of the Gqeberha high court,” the statement read.
Carter said while Equality Courts were accessible at most magistrate’s courts, it was necessary to have them available at a high court level too.
“The high court has the option to send a matter to any other forum. After accessing the matter the high court can then decide if the matter must be investigated by a different forum, such as the Gender Commission, or any other forum the court deems appropriate,” Carter said.
“The court cannot say ‘it is not my problem’ and send the matter elsewhere. It must still be actively involved in the redress.”
HeraldLIVE