The Herald

Lungisa revealed as state witness in multimillion-rand toilet tender case

ANC NEC member one of the people who provided police with information on the alleged fraudulent contract

ANC NEC member Andile Lungisa has been revealed as a state witness in the multimillion-rand toilet tender case
File photo.
State Witness ANC NEC member Andile Lungisa has been revealed as a state witness in the multimillion-rand toilet tender case File photo. Picture: Michael Pinyana

As the multimillion-rand corruption trial against Nelson Mandela Bay city manager Noxolo Nqwazi, suspended housing boss Mvuleni Mapu and their 10 co-accused kicked off on Monday, it emerged that Andile Lungisa would testify for the state.

ANC national executive committee member Lungisa was apparently one of the people who provided the police with information regarding the alleged fraudulent toilet tender.

The city’s commercial crime court also heard how the state would rely on the bank statements of the accused to prove their case.

Investigating officer Sergeant Yondela Ngaphi was the first witness to take the stand.

Nqwazi and Mapu face charges of fraud and contravening the Municipal Finance Act.

Their co-accused — businessman Morne van der Linde, his company HT Pelatona Logistics, Nompuzeo Ngothsa and her business Thuthiko Logistics, her daughter Nwabisa Masela and her husband Xolani Masela as well as ANC regional secretary Luyolo Nqakula, who has stepped aside from the position, and DOP members Mbulelo Victor Manyati, Trevor Louw and Neville Higgins — have been charged with money laundering, corruption and contravening the Prevention of the Organised Crime Act.

They all pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Questioned by state advocate Leigh-Anne Pillay-Selahle, Ngaphi said he had applied for bank statements in respect of the accused.

These, the prosecution believes, will show the questionable payments the accused allegedly received to bypass certain processes to award a R24.6m tender to HT Pelatona for the construction of 2,000 toilets around the Bay during the height of the Covid-19 pandemic and national lockdown. 

“I conducted a search at the offices of HT Pelatona in Welkom, looking for a contract and invoices with Thuthiko Logistics.

“But I did not find a contract. Instead, there were several invoices,” Ngaphi said.

Advocate Anneline Roestorf, for HT Pelatona, objected that the files and hard drives were taken while the state had failed to provide the defence with a single copy.

She described it as a trial by ambush.

“We’re not in favour of the manner in which the state is running this trial.

“We expect the state to provide the documents well in advance.

“The oversight by the state is unacceptable and infringes on the rights of the accused for a fair trial.

“The state had the opportunity to tender the documents ... and had ample time to get its house in order,” Roestorf said.

She said the defence would ask the investigating officer to stand down as a witness until they had been furnished with all outstanding documents.

Nqakula’s lawyer, advocate Siyabulela Mapoma SC, also asked that any and all outstanding documents be furnished before the trial resumed on Tuesday.

Pillay-Silahle said the state sought to establish the whereabouts of the hard drive seized from the HT Pelatona offices, which was expected to be furnished on Tuesday as part of their evidence in chief.

Nqwazi and Mapu sat quietly in the dock as the evidence was led.

It is alleged they bypassed certain processes to award the R24.6m tender to HT Pelatona.

According to the state, on April 17 2020, Mapu drafted a document as motivation for Nqwazi to approve the appointment of HT Pelatona but did not outline why the prescribed tender process could not be followed.

Less than a week later, Nqwazi signed the document presented to her by Mapu and R400,000 was subsequently paid into the bank account of Thuthiko Logistics.

Days later, R300,000 was reportedly paid into the bank account of Nwabisa, who subsequently transferred the money to her husband’s account.

Four days later, the money was allegedly paid to Nqakula’s account, who, in turn, paid Higgins, Manyathi and Louw, for what the state claims was gratification after they helped have Athol Trollip axed as mayor in September 2018.

Trollip was removed from office through a vote of no confidence.

The accused are all out on bail.

The trial continues.

HeraldLIVE