In a blow to the state’s case, the hearsay evidence heard during the trial of a man accused of murdering e-hailing driver Garrison Snayers was struck from the record after the state failed to call the witness who had made the damning allegations.
The man had implicated Bathandwa Jabavu and detailed the possible motive for the killing.
But as the state wound up its case in the Gqeberha high court on Monday, judge Nyameko Gqamana asked prosecutor Sivuyile McKay if he intended to call another witness to testify on the allegations that Snayers had been targeted for his race, with hopes that he might have a firearm.
Gqamana allowed the evidence to be heard with the proviso that McKay would call the witness to testify before the state closed its case.
McKay, however, told the court the witness would not be called and asked for the hearsay evidence to be struck from the record.
Gqamana accordingly ordered for that part of the state’s evidence be struck off the record in totality.
The allegations were first highlighted during the testimony of investigating officer Warrant Officer Phakamile Mndaweni, who had relayed the information he had been told by a colleague.
At the time, lawyer for Jabavu, advocate Siphokazi Cubungu, objected to the evidence being led as it was considered hearsay.
Last week, Jabavu pleaded not guilty to charges including conspiracy to commit robbery, murder, robbery, and the illegal possession of a firearm and ammunition.
He did not give a plea explanation but is expected to take the stand on Tuesday.
It is alleged Jabavu, along with now deceased Wandisile “Big Show” Gawe, and a third person who has since turned state witness, had plotted to lure an e-hailing taxi driver to Mandala Street, New Brighton, to rob him.
On February 17 2021, Snayers confirmed the pickup.
When he arrived at the pickup spot he was shot and killed while seated in his blue Suzuki Celerio.
He was robbed of his cellphone and an undisclosed amount of cash.
Jabavu and Gawe were arrested five days later.
Gawe was shot and killed in a separate incident before the trial began.
HeraldLIVE