The Herald

EU ruling threatens destruction of R600m in citrus exports

Large amount of the fruit from Eastern Cape farms, especially in Addo, Kirkwood and Patensie

About 2,000 shipping containers of SA citrus could be destroyed once it reaches Europe, because of non-compliance with regulations set by the EU
AT RISK: About 2,000 shipping containers of SA citrus could be destroyed once it reaches Europe, because of non-compliance with regulations set by the EU Picture: SUPPLIED

About 2,000 shipping containers of SA citrus could be destroyed once the shipment lands in Europe due to what is being described as unreasonable regulations imposed by the EU’s standing committee on plant, animal, food and feed (SCOPAFF).

If cooler heads do not prevail, the local industry could be dealt a R600m blow it may never recover from, and farmers already operating at non-existent profit margins could be forced to pack up their operations.

However, some industry experts are still holding on to the hope that the oranges, now en route to Europe by ship, will be accepted.

Otherwise, they will have to pull a rabbit out of a hat to find alternative markets.

The looming danger for SA citrus producers comes after the SCOPAFF introduced new cold storage and shipping regulations that require oranges to be shipped at lower temperatures than before to prevent the presence of false codling moths (FCM), which lay eggs under the peel.

The citrus industry’s special envoy to the EU, Deon Joubert, said once regulations like these were approved, there was usually a period of a couple of months given to importers to get their ducks in a row.

However, the new regulations were imposed on SA within a week of them being approved by the EU.

This left the 2,000 shipping containers, each valued at roughly R320,000, in limbo.

The shipment complied with regulations when it left SA shores, but the fruit will probably be deemed non-compliant when it arrives in Europe.

“This hasty decision by the EU smacks of discrimination against SA citrus,” Joubert said.

“All the usual implementation periods were ignored and there were never any discussions or notifications to the SA government.

“These regulations were implemented due to political pressure within the EU, and have no scientific basis.”

Up to 44% of SA’s annual citrus exports goes to Europe.

Of that figure, 20% goes to England and the remaining 80% to the rest of Europe.

“At this stage, we’re no longer negotiating with the EU,” Joubert said.

“We are targeting the ministries of individual European countries to see if we can come to some kind of agreement, or to see if they can put internal pressure on the EU to change its decision.

“If that fails, we can look for detours into Europe or for alternative markets.

“Both options come with huge financial implications.”

SA citrus is normally cooled to temperatures around 7°C before shipping.

Scientific evidence has proven this prevents the occurrence of FMC.

However, the new regulations, for the rest of 2022, will require citrus to be cooled to 5°C before shipping, posing serious challenges.

And from 2023, regulations will require citrus to be cooled to 2°C, which requires huge infrastructure upgrades.

Due to the cost implications and SA’s unreliable energy supply, these requirements could prove impossible.  

Asked what was behind the EU’s sudden decision to implement these regulations,  Sundays River Citrus Company managing director Hannes de Waal said there was much speculation, but one possibility was political pressure from the Spanish government as SA was one of its biggest competitors.

However, De Waal still had his fingers crossed that the citrus now en route to Europe would be accepted as its destruction could lead to a huge backlash for the EU.

“In a time where the world is in crisis, money is tight and food security is in question, it would be sacrilege to destroy that much fruit.”

De Waal said a large amount of the fruit on its way to Europe came from Eastern Cape farms, more specifically in Addo, Kirkwood and Patensie.

“In the current economic climate indications are that many of our farms will not turn a profit this year,” he said.

“This trickles down the entire value chain and affects the exporters, cold storage operators, logistics companies, farmers, farmworkers and everyone with a hand in the industry.

“There’s no way the industry can absorb a R600m blow and keep moving forward.

“It will be devastating.”   

HeraldLIVE