AN Eastern Cape game reserve is aiming to reintroduce elephants to land they last ranged upon more than 200 years ago. Samara, the biggest private game reserve in the Eastern Cape, is aiming to take the giant step this year following groundbreaking research by experts at NMMU.
Situated south-east of Graaff-Reinet on the Camdeboo Plains at the foot of the Sneeuberg, the 28330ha reserve straddles an ancient elephant migration route, it is now becoming clear. This route, explains Samara owner Sarah Tompkins, ran from the elephant-laden coastal belt around the Sundays and Great Fish rivers into the hinterland.
It was last used in the late 1700s when these migrant elephant herds were hunted to extinction.
At the heart of the Eastern Cape Midlands portion of the Great Karoo linking Graaff- Reinet, Cradock and Middelburg, the arid Camdeboo doesn't look at first glance like elephant country. But as the late Dr Jack Skead reminds in his Historical Incidences in the Cape Province Volume 2, there are elephants in Namibia today which thrive in much drier conditions.
Skead records various elephant tusk, bone and molar findings in the area, including a complete skeleton on the farm Matjieshoek between Murraysburg and Graaff-Reinet. "The completeness of the skeleton disposes of any possibility that the remains represent a discarded trophy of an animal shot elsewhere."
Skead quotes as well from a 1778 document noting how Great Fish River farmer Willem Prinsloo and his three sons headed north through this region to the Groote Rivier (today the Orange River) "to shoot elephants".
Skead mulls that this short account could provide insight as to why later travellers described no sightings of elephants in the Eastern Cape Midlands.
"Would they have been shot out by expeditions like this? On the other hand why did the Prinsloos have to go into this less hospitable country than the coastal strip where they lived? The hope of better ivory, perhaps?"
The report by the Terrestrial Ecology Research Unit (Teru), now the Centre for African Conservation Ecology, at NMMU says the unearthing of elephant remains in the inland reaches of the Sundays River valley dating back 500 years, but some as little as 250 years old, prove jumbos did once occur in this area and the Sundays "could have served as a migration corridor.
"Similar remains in the Cradock area suggest the Great Fish River valley may also have served this purpose. The evidence suggests the elephants also undertook local movements between adjacent river valleys."
As mixed feeders elephants can graze and browse so this would have aided them as they trekked back and forth between the coast and the Great Karoo. They would have been guided by season and availability of food and water, but also by pressure from humans hunting them in their coastal range for ivory, for sport and to protect crops.
As Camdeboo naturalist and historian David McNaughton notes, the cattle of the trekboer and Khoikhoi would have also played a role. These farmers would have established settlements near water for their cattle and thereby come into direct conflict with elephants which needed the resource just as much.
A member of fifth generation settler stock, McNaughton recalls the story of how his father, Andrew, in about 1950 discovered a large elephant bone protruding from the bank of a tributary of the Melk River before the farm was incorporated into Samara. He transported the bone home tied across the saddle of his horse and it was later donated to the Albany Museum in Grahamstown.
Another key link here is the rediscovered gravesite of a Korana chief on a Camdeboo farm near the Swart River, the most north-west tributary of the Sundays. Comprising a large cairn of stones which would have been individually placed by mourners, in line with Khoikhoi custom, the site is still clearly visible.
The important thing, McNaughton notes, is how the chief died. Describing this gravesite, renowned explorer Capt Robert Gordon writes in a November 13 1777 entry in his diary that the chief "was killed by an elephant".
So, up the Great Fish and Little Fish rivers then, the jumbos would have trekked, en route to the Orange but likely not going as far every time, browsing on riverine forest and branching out into spekboom where they could find it, perhaps moving west to link with the tributaries of the Sundays, the Vogel and the three rivers which flow through Samara -- Plat, Monkey and Melk.
Or perhaps from Addo just straight up the Sundays through Kirkwood, west at what today is the Darlington Dam, or keeping north up the Vogel across the plains of Camdeboo.
The value of the elephant is now better understood, the Teru report explains. To bring in the tourists of course, but also, when carrying capacity is in balance, as a positive catalyst for biodiversity.
As important seed dispersal agents, their bulk forces growing space for more species. Their wallows act as moisture and nutrient traps. Two herds are planned for Samara.
Driving into the reserve from the west, the mountains are blue ships on a flat sea. A klipspringer bounds away then turns to look.
On the slopes where teams are rehabilitating the spekboom – king of carbon sequesters and favourite food of the African elephant -- large grey shapes are moving. Or could it be our imagination? The clouds scud and the wind wields. The past and the present are colliding beautifully at Samara.